Messages of Support for Ravi’s January 2024 ICE Check-In

On January 12 at 8 am, Ravi will go for another ICE supervision check-in — his last before his deferred action expires.

Over 50 people have personally attested to why it is so essential that Ravi at last be free from ICE surveillance and able to live and organize with his community.

If you would like to submit a message of support, please do so through this link.

“Ravi has done everything that he has been asked to do. He is an upstanding member of the community and it is cruel and unusual punishment to continue this long after it should have been resolved by letting him stay in the country. Ravi is an asset to our community and this country.” – Marie Studer

“Ravi is a good man of high moral character and a leader for the forgotten and downtrodden. He is a treasure in this country, not a liability. He is beloved by his community and his family and it is cruel to separate him from them forever for a nonviolent offense that happened years ago – and when he has shown again and again since then that he is not a criminal. Our immigration laws are cruel and unforgiving and, in his case, applied vindictively. Please show compassion and kind justice, free Ravi from surveillance, and do not deport him!” – Anonymous

“Ravi Ragbir has helped thousands of immigrants find their footing in New York. At this moment, when New York is challenged to show the world how to greet those fleeing persecution and danger in their home countries, embrace Mr. Ragbir. Empower him to keep doing his generous outreach by granting him a secure home with his family in the U.S.” – Mary Watkins

“Ravi is an example of faithful humanity and warrants just opportunity to live his life fully and freely with loved ones and community in accord with the Universal Human Rights belonging to us all, especially since he exemplifies the meaning of those rights justly lived. May he have every opportunity to live and love in this land with all that he values. May Ravi be an example of justice in America with the full exercise of human freedom to be all we are meant to be for good in our national life. He is a blessing; may he live that fully among us.” – Mark Meeks

[It is essential for Ravi to be free from ICE surveillance] “Because he has been a wonderful support of people seeking asylum and he will continue to do that good work. There is no reason why he should, after all these years, still have to report to ICE. He should be free to remain in the U.S. with his family.” – Donna Gould

“This country we call home was created with the right to be free & speak out as guaranteed by the constitution/amendments. No family should be separated by an error in life, if born here you serve your time & then home, for many immigrants it’s directly the opposite. I pray & hope that he is free from this check in, able to stay & continue to advocate from the heart. When I met him many years ago I was impressed with his persona.” – Norma

“Ravi is not a threat to our community. He is a pacifist and a caring individual that spends his time volunteering to help others. There should be no reason he should have to check in. He follows the law and hasn’t tried to leave the country. It’s time for Ravi to be able to live his life without ICE check ins hanging over him. Ravi is an asset to our community. He spends so much of his time offering help and aid to others in need. There should be more people like Ravi. He is also my sister’s husband and life partner. A very big part of our family. An Uncle to my children and a friend.” – Beth Steinman

[It is essential for Ravi to be free from ICE surveillance] “Because he is a force for good in the community and has made a productive, contributing life here. He is no threat to society. He is the opposite and we need more like him and his family!” – Tammy Pittman

“Ravi is a beloved member of the New York community. He’s respected and has only ever tried to do good for the benefit of others. He is in no way a threat and he should be free from these ICE check-ins. Ravi has been a mentor to younger people; New York is his home and he deserves to stay.” – Thanu Yakupitiyage

“Ravi is an integral and key leader in our communities. The trauma and continued aggression this surveillance adds must end.” – Rev. Dr. Robin Tanner

“His presence in this country has brought an important voice for a more just United States. He is a loving, caring man who has a beautiful family and fostered an enormous community who are with him to secure his right to remain in this country! We need more Ravis among us!” – Anita Altman

“He has done no wrong and contributes greatly to values the U.S. holds dear.” – Jacob POiheny

“Ravi is an amazing human being who has brought so much love and justice to the world!” – Julia

“He provides an essential service to people who are dealing with immigration check-ins as well as with immigration judges. I participated in his accompaniment program. Sometimes we had to stay outside of the courtroom and we did but sometimes the judge allowed us in as in the case of a young woman from Central America who spoke no English, only a dialect. I do believe that Ravi is being targeted because he has helped and tried to help many people.He has taught people to stand up for their rights. He has lived a good and useful life and therefore should be allowed to stay.” – Mary Ann Fastook

“Ravi is an upstanding member of society. He has helped thousands of others who have been detained and/or harassed by ICE. He and his family have been through a lot because of antiquated, outdated and unjust immigration policies. It’s time to put this emotional and psychological torment to an end. Ravi has complied with all legal requirements and should be released from having to do check-ins.” – Reverend Ross Upshaw

“Ravi is a devoted family man who has been a strong supporter of immigrant rights along with providing a legal path to citizenship. Ravi is a man of integrity who, in the past had some legal issues (unjust) but dealt with them and paid his debt. The time is long past that he have this unfair burden removed and let him continue to show his strength of conviction and his love for his adopted country.” – Sidney Gottlieb

“Ravi has shown again and again that he is not a danger. Rather he contributes to his community and is an excellent example of someone who aims to help his community. He has already paid an excessively high price and his record should be cleared NOW.” – JoAnne Hadden

“Ravi is an asset to be in our community. We want him ‘free.’ We are grateful for Ravi’s contributions to our community now – and in the future.” – Mary Smith

“Ravi has proven himself to be a positive community member and he lives here with his family! It makes no sense to continue this surveillance as he has done nothing that merits such. Frankly, this surveillance seems punitive and designed to cause humiliation for no reason. I have heard Ravi speak and I have seen him and his wife as they work together to raise awareness of the cruelty of our immigration system. I see him as a force for good!” – Gabrielle Shatan

“Ravi has proven his American commitment to constitutional justice, civil mercy, and soulful hospitality. He is a key, kind, leader. We are a better people because of Ravi. His courage, spirit, faith, soul force resemble the best of what we aspire as humans and as Americans. Enough is enough. Stop this madness and release his bonds.” – Rev. David H. Rommereim

“Ravi is an invaluable leader and member of his community here in NYC, and the way he has been treated is a clear attempt at retaliation against an outspoken immigrant rights’ champion. The only justifiable path forward is to allow him the status of permanent resident, so that he can remain with his family and loved ones here in the US.” – Dr. Max Osborn

“Ravi is an asset to our community and has done everything possible to support those in need. Ravi is an honest, sincere and dedicated individual who loves America and its values.” – Judith Goldberg

“Surveillance by ICE or any agency is an infringement on the right to privacy. Ravi has lived in the US for decades and should be permitted to enjoy the right to privacy. Ravi’s work on behalf of undocumented people shows him to be a community leader and activist. We need more people like Ravi in this country.” – Rabbi Barat Ellman

“His story is an example of why we should welcome newcomers to this country; he takes community building as his human responsibility, is an educator, and acts on behalf of others. It’s way over due: let Ravi be free of surveillance and allow him to live a productive, active, peaceful life here.” – Linny Stovall

“I value Ravi as a United States resident after all this time. He is settled with his family and has done so much good for New Yorkers. Why is this not enough for you?! With the immigration backlog as it is and with the cost of reviewing his case year in and year out, I protest my tax money being used in this wasteful and cruel way.” – Sigrid Meinel

“Ravi has been a critical part of the immigrant rights and representation community in New York City and beyond. To allow him to continue that important work (and for many other reasons), he should not be forced to live under the threat of constant surveillance. Moreover, the fact that he is under such surveillance is a troubling sign of the personal risks that exercising the right to speak out created during the Trump administration and creates the risk of chilling other speech now.” – Lindsay Nash

“He’s a wonderful New Yorker!.” – Anonymous

“Immigration needs to stop harassing Ravi and grant him permanent status. ICE is targeting him because of his political activities supporting migrants who have been detained or who are threatened with deportation. Enough is enough!” – Stephan Russo

“He has done his time and moved towards helping others and has made a life here with his wife and family and community” – Anonymous

“Ravi has worked tirelessly for the rights of immigrants and has conducted himself with exemplary courage. What is the point of these continual check-ins? I believe Ravi is the kind of person we should welcome to our country. He has the gift of bringing people together – – a quality which is greatly needed nowadays.” – Sima szaluta

“Ravi is an exemplary human being who deserves to live free from ICE surveillance. He poses neither a flight risk nor a danger to public safety. Ravi Ragbir spoke as a guest lecturer to my students at Berkeley Law in 2021 alongside Alina Das. My students were enormously grateful that Ravi shared his wealth of experience and found the class deeply moving. One described hearing from Ravi to me as the most impactful experience of their law school education. I hope countless others are allowed the opportunity to interact with and learn from Ravi Ragbir.” – Leti Volpp

“Selective enforcement is unconstitutional. It seems clear that Ravi is being watched and harassed because of his political speech, and citizen or not, standards must be the same for all—free speech is absolute, barring only directly inciting violence or making specific threats. I urge you to resolve this quickly in Ravi’s favor so that he and Amy can finally relax and focus on their productive lives with family and friends.” – Sally Jane Gellert

“It is such a waste of time and resources to continue to monitor Ravi when he has paid his debt to society many times over. He is a valuable member of our community, has a loving family, and deserves to be able to live his life here in the United States out from under the threat of deportation.” – Patti I

“ENOUGH IS ENOUGH! Our immigration system is broken. Ravi has experienced the worst of our deportation system because of a single criminal conviction for fraud in 2006. He has been incarcerated and has spent every year since meeting the requirements of our immigration system. Ravi is my son-in-law and over the years I have gotten to know a kind, thoughtful, considerate person and at times funny. I cannot imagine him being deported. In addition, Ravi is needed by those many other immigrants who need advice and education regarding their stay in the US. He is an advocate and always working on different ways to work in his community.” - Gale Gottlieb

“Ravi has more than proven his honesty and reliability. The continued surveillance is simply harassment and is a waste of time and tax payer money. Ravi is the sort of person we should be welcoming to the US. No one of us can afford to be judged by a single mistake. He has more than redeemed himself through his love and friendships and service to so many. We need him here.” – Mary Meyer

“Ravi has proven productive in America and continue to show up in his community. Please free Ravi from ICE check-ins.” – Melissa Springs-Mozumder

“In our community and family, Ravi plays a pivotal role, contributing significantly to our collective growth and well-being. His freedom from surveillance is crucial not only for respecting his personal dignity and privacy but also for allowing him to continue his positive and active participation in our lives. He has consistently demonstrated his commitment to our community’s values, fostering relationships built on trust and respect. Surveillance would not only impede his ability to contribute meaningfully but also cause undue stress and anxiety, which could hinder his personal growth and the valuable support he provides to our family. Keeping him free from undue scrutiny is not only a matter of personal liberty but also essential for nurturing his continued positive influence in our community and family.” – Jeremy Steinman

[It is essential for Ravi to be free from ICE surveillance] “So he and his family may live in peace as they continue to help and give to others.” – Melissa Stoner

“His family needs him, our community needs him, also, immigrants need him” – Rosalinda Martinez 

“The check-ins that ICE has forced Ravi to endure over the years are unnecessary and cruel. Ravi has never missed a check-in and has complied with the years and years rigorous limits in his life and freedom. ICE should eliminate the one-size-fits-all approach and take a careful look at Ravi (and millions of others) cases to stop these traumatizing check-ins. 2024 is your year Ravi!!!! Sending love.” – Jessica Beaumont

“As Ravi has demonstrated over and over again, our immigration system refuses to treat noncitizens in this country with humanity and dignity. No one should be subjected to the sort of treatment and surveillance Ravi has endured over so many years.” – Antonia House

“It is essential for Ravi be free of ICE surveillance so that he can more effectively and substantially do the organizing work and accompaniment for immigrants and their families. Without the time consuming ( as well as the demoralizing) aspects of ICE surveillance, Ravi Ragbir would be able to provide more focused and creative energy to the spiritual justice work he is called to do on behalf of the larger communities in New York City and beyond. Ravi has done this work for many years on behalf of us all while having to be concerned about his own immigration status and concerns about deportation. He has done more good throughout the United States and deserves to be removed from surveillance by ICE or any other organization. I have worked with Ravi for decades now. He is an accomplished organizer with so many gifts. Yet he has had this painful weight he carries, never knowing what may come next. He has served selflessly, giving to his community and the nation in countless ways. Please remove this burden from him and his family– indeed removing this barrier from him will enable justice to move forward for all those who are impacted by the gracious work he does.” – Rev. Susan Karlson 

“I am writing as a citizen concerned for Ravi Ragbir, a colleague I admire both professionally and personally. He should be permitted to live in this country, free from ICE surveillance and harassment. Ravi strengthens the United States through his advocacy work with immigrants and the faith community and also by his commitment to his wife and daughter, both US citizens. I am continually impressed by the hard work and practical attitudes in advocating for social justice shown by Ravi and his wife. Ravi should be free of the worry and pressure of ICE surveillance to carry on these efforts. Thank you. He inspires us all — his friends, his family, his church and the immigrant community.” – Kathleen Ferris Heim

“Ravi Ragbir is a good man who spends his energy in service to the well-being of others. He is also an essential presence to his family. Deporting Ravi would be a loss to all those people and to the country as a whole. Certainly, Ravi’s presence in the US is not in any way a danger to our country. On the contrary. It is an asset. Please remove the constant threat of deportation and grant Ravi Ragvir permanent residence. Thank you.” – Jane Treuhold

“We have known Ravi for more than eleven years. We have never met an individual who works so hard helping others and for his beliefs. We have been at numerous meetings with various organizations that work in behalf of the needy in the city and very frequently found that many people knew Ravi either personally or were aware of the work he does on behalf of the immigrants. We know that he is a tireless and selfless worker for the men and women of this city and an important leader of his community. The time has come for an end to the ICE surveillance of this outstanding individual who does so much for our society.

As Executive Director of the New Sanctuary Coalition of New York City Ravi has facilitated the efforts of many faith communities and community organizations to aid immigrants and support their rights in several ways. He helps individual immigrants navigate the legal system, such as by teaching them their rights and assisting them in filling out the various forms they need. He has also trained many volunteers to perform these kinds of tasks. Ravi inspires people to act on their desire to help immigrants and has great skill in organization. These attributes allow him to excel at coordinating the activities of many churches, temples, mosques, and other community groups in our city. He always makes the people who come to him for help feel welcome and makes them realize that someone cares for them. Beyond this, his ‘people skills’ have connected him with citizens throughout the city and metropolitan region, including politicians, business leaders, the police, and other groups. Few people in the New York area are widely known by just a first name; Ravi is one of them. Continued ICE surveillance on Mr. Ragbir is not necessary and indeed tears at the fabric of the institutions that hold our society together and keep it free. It must end now.

Mr. Ragbir is a committed family man. We have also known his wife, Amy Gottlieb, an immigrant rights leader with American Friends Service Committee, for many years. We have always been impressed by the love that was palpable between Amy and Ravi. Amy, like Ravi is passionate about the ideals on which this nation is based and a pillar of the community. Both Amy and his daughter, Deborah, are U.S. citizens. His deportation would be a severe disruption to this family. Two U.S. citizens would be deprived of the care of a husband and father. His surveillance by ICE is a true shame and does not reflect the values of the country we all are living in.” – Marisa and David Lohse

“I am personally acquainted with Ravi Ragbir and feel he is doing important work advocating for the immigrant community, which should continue. He is an asset to his community and the United States, compassionate, intelligent, rational and committed. Ravi should be permitted to remain in the United States without needing to go through the periodic check-in procedures he has been subjected to for many years. He has a wife and daughter, both of whom are citizens. They need him here and the country needs him here. Thank you.” – Jeffrey Heim

“It is essential for Ravi to be free from ICE surveillance. Ravi is a thoughtful, hardworking and caring man who has provided important support the a range of individuals in his community.” – Peggy McNamara

“Ravi paid whatever debt society required of him and should be free to live his life as a law-abiding person in this country. He has stood up for others and been a source of support to many who are going through similar troubles” – Maxine Phillips

“Ravi has helped many immigrants, and his wife Amy, does all kinds of work for justice. These are good people who shouldn’t have to live in fear of his deportation for speaking up.” – Anonymous

“Yes he’s an upstanding citizen. Ravi has helped so many immigrants find their way, given endless hours to help those in need.” – Kim Kelly 

“Ravi is a dedicated immigration activist fighting for others. He also has a family here. It seems the targeting of Mr. Ragbir is mostly because he is an outspoken activist.” – Suresh Dianand

“Ravi has proven himself to be a faithful friend and supporter of positive causes in this country and is needed by his friends and family. His absence would be painfully felt by many.” – Daniel Shenk

“I’ve known Ravi for a decade and have watched his work and care for people. He participates in creating a better society. He is what American is at its best. I’ve heard Ravi speak publicly many times. I am always impressed with his passion, wisdom, and knowledge. I admire him.” – Matthew Nelson

PRESS RELEASE: Immigrant Rights Leader Ravi Ragbir Receives Three-Year Deferred Action After Reaching Settlement on First Amendment Suit Challenging ICE Retaliation

For Immediate Release: February 24, 2022


Press Release: Immigrant Rights Leader Ravi Ragbir Receives Three-Year Deferred Action After Reaching Settlement on First Amendment Suit Challenging ICE Retaliation

February 24, 2022 — Three years after prominent activist Ravi Ragbir and immigrant rights organizations New Sanctuary Coalition of New York City, CASA, Detention Watch Network, the National Immigration Project of the National Lawyers Guild, and the New York Immigration Coalition filed suit to challenge the targeting of immigrant rights activists by federal immigration officials, the parties have settled the suit and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”) has agreed to grant Mr. Ragbir three years of deferred action in the United States. 

“For all of these years my family, friends, and community were worried that I would be targeted by ICE because of my outspokenness. They were right—my public challenges to the system led them to retaliate against me,” said Mr. Ragbir. “This victory is a testimony to the power of the community working together to stand up against ICE and an oppressive policy, to support human rights and dignity for all. I am celebrating this step towards victory, but knowing that this is not the end, and that we must continue in the struggle to end deportation. I want to recognize my privilege of having the smartest and best attorneys representing me, Stanton Jones and William Perdue from the firm Arnold and Porter and Alina Das and Jessica Rofé and the students from the NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic.”

This period of deferred action also gives Mr. Ragbir a chance to pursue other legal remedies in order to gain permanent immigration relief in the United States.

“Ravi and I are deeply grateful to our brilliant legal team, our loving families and friends, and to everyone in our community who have stood with us during these years of struggle and who made it possible for us to have this moment to celebrate,” said Amy Gottlieb, wife of Mr. Ragbir and Associate Regional Director of American Friends Service Committee. “Three years to breathe free as we work toward a permanent solution is a wonderful holiday gift.”

“I am very pleased that after a long struggle Ravi has finally been granted deferred action,” said Congressman Jerrold Nadler. “I have long advocated on behalf of Ravi, he is a passionate leader and immigration activist. Today’s settlement affirms that ICE cannot target someone for deportation simply for speaking out and exercising their 1st Amendment protected rights.”

The lawsuit was supported by numerous faith leaders, immigrant rights organizations, elected officials, activists, and others who spoke out on behalf of protecting immigrants’ First Amendment rights. 

“Finally, some good news after more than a year of hardship and tragedy,” said Murad Awawdeh, Executive Director, New York Immigration Coalition. “Ravi Ragbir is one of our movement’s most outspoken critics of ICE and has paid the consequences of that outspokenness when he was detained and threatened with deportation to a country that he hadn’t lived in for years. Today, Ravi and his family will finally be able to breathe a sigh of temporary relief thanks to the government’s agreement to allow him three years of deferred action. This isn’t the permanent legal status that we hoped for him and the millions of others just like Ravi, who have been struggling to attain a pathway to citizenship. But it’s something. In the meantime, the NYIC will continue to fight for permanent legal protections for the hundreds of thousands of immigrant New Yorkers who continue to live in the shadows while dreaming and hoping for this country to recognize them as the Americans they already are.”

“Ravi has been a strong advocate and leader in the fight to have a truly just immigration system,” said Congresswoman Nydia Velázquez. “I’m proud to have supported and advocated for Ravi during this difficult journey. It has been a long road and I’m grateful to all who protested and showed up for Ravi throughout the years. These three years of deferred action gives everyone involved a chance to breathe, and while we celebrate this huge victory, we must remember that this is not the end of the fight.”

In February 2018, Mr. Ragbir and immigrant rights organizations filed suit against federal immigration agencies because of the targeting that Mr. Ragbir experienced as a result of his outspoken activism against U.S. immigration policies. On January 11, 2018, he was abruptly detained by ICE after years of routine check-ins. ICE’s decision to detain Mr. Ragbir came at the heels of its similarly abrupt arrest and detention of Jean Montrevil, a co-founder of New Sanctuary Coalition, that same month. ICE deported Mr. Montrevil and attempted to do the same to Mr. Ragbir before a federal court ordered his release. Through their actions, ICE officials made clear their resentment of Mr. Ragbir’s and Mr. Montrevil’s activism and critique of the numerous flaws of the U.S. immigration system. 

“ICE targeted Ravi for speaking out against the cruel injustices of our immigration system, thereby putting him into a yearslong fight to remain with his family and community. While we are grateful that Ravi will be able to live without fear of deportation for 3 years, we are also committed to finding a permanent solution to his case and all others like him. As we work to make our vision of a humane and compassionate immigration system a reality, it is clear that we need bold and courageous allies like Ravi by our side,” said Sirine Shebaya, Executive Director of the National Immigration Project.

“Ravi’s story is a testament to the unimaginable courage it requires to speak out against injustice. And this three-year reprieve is a testament to the power of community to end the harms of retaliation. We are grateful for this respite. But so long as Ravi, and countless others, remain in legal limbo, we know they are not truly safe,” said Jessica Rofé of the NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic and one of Ravi Ragbir’s lawyers. “We hope the next three years will lead to permanent immigration relief for Ravi and others, whose advocacy and activism reflect the bedrock of American democratic principles.”

Even after Mr. Ragbir’s release from detention in January 2018, ICE continued to pursue Mr. Ragbir’s deportation, prompting the New Sanctuary Coalition of New York City, CASA, Detention Watch Network, the National Immigration Project of the National Lawyers Guild, and the New York Immigration Coalition to join Mr. Ragbir in filing suit (Ragbir v. Homan) to challenge the targeting of immigrant rights activists by federal immigration officials. The suit alleged that the specific actions against Mr. Ragbir, along with similar retaliatory actions against activists across the country, were part of a pattern and practice of unlawful targeting in violation of the First Amendment. 

The district court denied Mr. Ragbir’s motion for a preliminary injunction and dismissed the claims challenging his deportation under the First Amendment. On appeal, the Second Circuit vacated that decision, concluding that the alleged retaliatory deportation by ICE was sufficiently “outrageous” to violate the First Amendment, and that the Constitution requires judicial review of these claims. However, the Supreme Court remanded the case to the Second Circuit on jurisdictional grounds, questioning whether federal courts have jurisdiction to hear such First Amendment claims. The case was eventually sent back to the Southern District of New York to litigate these jurisdictional issues before the parties officially settled the case. 

“This is a victory not just for Ravi, but for immigrants, for their communities, and for the First Amendment,” said William Perdue of Arnold & Porter.  “Ravi has had the courage to fight for a fair and humane immigration system, and his case stands as a warning to ICE and public officials of all kinds that they cannot abuse their powers by retaliating against those who speak out against them.  Ravi’s relentless advocacy is an inspiration, and his settlement reaffirms that if the First Amendment means anything, it means being free to criticize the government without fear of reprisal.”

“Detention Watch Network is thrilled to hear that long time member, Ravi Ragbir, has been granted deferred action and will have a respite from years of facing deportation including some in immigration detention and on an electronic monitor,” said Silky Shah, Executive Director of the Detention Watch Network. “Ravi is a tireless and selfless defender of freedom not just for himself, but for all immigrants. Congratulations to Ravi and the team that supported him on this important movement victory!”

“For years, communities of faith around the country have been praying for this relief. Why? Because we need Ravi. Because Ravi leads us in doing God’s work. I expect this to be but the first step in our collective gratitude and recognition for Ravi’s crucial work. And so we continue,” shared Reverend Kaji Dousa, Senior Minister and C.E.O. of Park Avenue Christian Church.
“Ravi has fearlessly spoken out against the injustice of detention and deportation. He should never have been targeted for his activism. We are thrilled that he has been granted deferred action. We need his voice in the movement now more than ever,” said Alina Das of the NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic and one of Ravi Ragbir’s lawyers.

An Update on My First Amendment Case

I have “good news” to share with you. The Government has agreed not to deport me for the next three years, as part of a settlement agreement in my First Amendment lawsuit. That gives us three more years to pursue other forms of relief that I need to be able to remain in the US permanently.  You can read more in The Intercept here. We have a lot of work to do, but I know that in community we can get there.  

Over the years, Amy and I have experienced so many excruciating moments in our interactions with ICE that we thought we were numb. In fact, when I was released from detention in 2018 I was back to work the next day.  So when a friend recently asked Amy how we were going to commemorate that Jan 11, 2022 was four years since ICE tried to deport me in 2018, Amy, my defense committee and I were taken aback. Jan 11 2018 and the days that followed were intense and very traumatic for all of us. I thought that I was unfazed because I had lived through so many such days with ICE. I was even making bad jokes with ICE officers who were there to make sure that I was deported.

But when Amy was describing what happened on that day I watched myself break down. My eyes teared up, my pain exuded from my pores and entered my nose, suffocating me. I could not stop trembling. I am not the only one who suffers from this type of PTSD. This happens to every Friend/person, their loved ones and their communities who have to live with the threat of deportation. 

Now we are deeply relieved to have this breathing time, and to know that 2022 is the first year that I will not have to report to ICE at all. I will have to report in 2023 and 2024, and will of course seek your support when that happens.

I know that this ‘victory’ is due to all of the love and support that you, my community, have provided.  I look forward to being able to be together sometime soon.

With gratitude and love,
Ravi

Press Release: Legal Experts Urge Biden Administration to Protect Immigrants’ First Amendment Rights

New Complaint Describes Widespread Practice of Retaliation Against Immigrant Activists

July 19, 2021 — The Immigrant Rights Clinic at New York University School of Law (“NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic) and the Cornell Law School First Amendment Clinic (“Cornell First Amendment Clinic”) filed a joint complaint with the Department of Homeland Security Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties (OCRCL) alleging a widespread pattern of retaliation by federal immigration officials against immigrant activists and others who publicly criticize U.S. immigration policy. The complaint urges immediate action to protect those who have already been targeted for their activism and policy changes to ensure such retaliation does not occur in the future.

“Far too many immigrants live in fear that if they speak up for their rights, they will be targeted for arrest and deportation,” says Alina Das, Professor of Clinical Law and Co-Director of the NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic. “So long as federal immigration officials are free to target immigrants with impunity, the immigrant rights movement is in peril.”

The NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic documented more than one thousand instances of First Amendment retaliation in recent years, including the cases of prominent activists Claudio Rojas, Jean Montrevil, and Ravi Ragbir. Federal immigration officials in Miami detained and deported Mr. Rojas to Argentina in 2019 after a documentary film, The Infiltrators, debuted at the Sundance Film Festival, featuring his activism. Federal immigraiton officials in New York detained Mr. Montrevil and Mr. Ragbir in 2018 after they spoke critically of the agency as part of the sanctuary movement, deporting Mr. Montrevil to Haiti shortly thereafter. DHS continues to pursue Mr. Ragbir’s deportation to Trinidad and Tobago. The complaint asks DHS to exercise its discretion to protect these individuals and others from the harm of First Amendment retaliation, and seeks broader policy changes. 

“The First Amendment has always been the foundation of progress and the cornerstone of democracy in the United States,” says Jared Carter, Associate Director of the Cornell Law School First Amendment Clinic. “The Biden Administration must end policies that violate the basic First Amendment principle that no person should be subject to government retaliation for exercising their First Amendment rights to freedom of speech or freedom of assembly.”

###

Watch: Congressional Briefing on Immigrant Rights Activists Under Attack

On January 13, 2021, the New Sanctuary Coalition, the Immigrant Rights Clinic at NYU School of Law, the National Immigrant Justice Center, Migrant Justice, and the Immigrant Justice Network held a panel discussion with targeted leaders of the immigrant rights movement. Clinic students also presented an interactive map highlighting the breadth of the government’s campaign to silence immigrant leaders. With the Biden Administration soon to take office, this moment calls for a public reckoning of our country’s immigration policy. Immigrant voices must be protected and centered in this conversation. The briefing addressed what members of Congress can do to defend and prevent further retaliation against the rights of their constituents and members of the immigrant community.

Also see the English-language transcript here. [Spanish version is in the works.]

Listen and/or download the audio here:

Media Advisory Wed 1/13: Congressional Briefing: Immigrant Rights Activists Targeted by DHS Call for Relief and Accountability on the Eve of Biden Inauguration

WHAT: Congressional Briefing: Immigrant Rights Activists Targeted by DHS Call for Relief and Accountability on the Eve of Biden Inauguration 

WHEN: Jan 13, 2021 2 – 3 PM ET 

WHERE: Virtual (Zoom). Please RSVP here

DETAILS: Targeted immigrant rights leaders will speak at a virtual congressional briefing to address how agencies within the Department of Homeland Security retaliate against immigrants for exercising their protected First Amendment rights. Scheduled to speak are: Enrique “Kike” Balcazar, Alejandra Pablos, Ravi Ragbir, Jahsiah Montrevil, Rev. Kaji Spellman Douša. 

This briefing will highlight how immigrant rights activists have faced arrest, deportation, detention, retaliation inside detention centers, and surveillance for standing up to injustices in their community. The Immigrant Rights Clinic at NYU Law School has documented over 1,000 publicly-reported cases of retaliation and surveillance. The breadth of these abuses are evidence of how federal agencies are undermining core tenets of an open, free society.  

The briefing will focus attention on the urgent need for Congress and the incoming Biden Administration to provide immediate forms of immigration relief to targeted activists and to pursue accountability measures that can reign in the unchecked authority of these agencies. Members of Congress will discuss what elected officials can do to redress these wrongs.

Additional information about the campaign to end First Amendment retaliation is available at: immigrantrightsvoices.org 

SPONSORS

  • Rep. Jerrold Nadler (NY-10) 
  • Rep. Yvette Clarke (NY-9) 
  • Rep. Nydia Velazquez (NY-7)
  • Rep. Pramila Jayapal (WA-7) 
  • New Sanctuary Coalition 
  • Immigrant Rights Clinic at NYU Law School
  • Migrant Justice 
  • Immigrant Justice Network 

###

Year End Greetings from Ravi and Amy

Ravi and Amy in Orient, NY in early October 2020. Credit: Loris Guzzetta

Dear Community,

As this challenging year draws to a close, we write to share a message of hope with you, our family and community.

The last time we wrote to you directly, we included our hope that we’d have a new president-elect. Well, here we are, a few months later, and in fact that hope has been achieved. We will have a new president, and some of the devastating stressors that we have all lived under for the last four years may be alleviated. At the same time, Ravi’s case is far from resolved, but we continue to hold out our hopes that with all of your support, the threat of deportation will be lifted and we’ll be able to live our lives at peace.

We also share a bit of good news: Ravi has a stay of deportation because of our First Amendment lawsuit against ICE retaliation, and his check-in that was scheduled for tomorrow, December 18, has been moved to May 13, 2021. We are grateful for this reprieve, and of course for all of your accompaniment in this very long process.

We know the fight is long over, and the harm to our communities runs deep. ICE has targeted, surveilled and retaliated against so many immigrant rights activists, instances of retaliation which are documented here. But through it all, we know that together we will win this and we will move toward justice and fairness for everyone.

Our very best wishes to each and every one of you.

Love, Amy and Ravi

Immigrant Rights Voices Map Launch // Lanzamiento del sitio “Immigrant Rights Voices”

español sigue

NEW MAP EXPOSES OVER ONE THOUSAND INCIDENTS OF GOVERNMENT RETALIATION AND SURVEILLANCE AGAINST IMMIGRANT RIGHTS ACTIVISTS

In response to widespread efforts to silence immigrant communities, the NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic and New Sanctuary Coalition Launch #ProtectImmigrantVoices Campaign 

For immediate release

November 1, 2020 — The New York University School of Law Immigrant Rights Clinic (IRC) and New Sanctuary Coalition (NSC) announce the launch of the Immigrant Rights Voices website and the #ProtectImmigrantVoices campaign.  The Immigrant Rights Voices website features an interactive map documenting over a thousand instances of retaliation against immigrant rights defenders by numerous federal government agencies and highlights the personal accounts of immigrant rights leaders who have been arrested, jailed, surveilled, and deported for their activism. By abusing its immense power in an attempt to stamp out dissenting voices in immigrant communities, the government is flagrantly trampling on our First Amendment right to speak truth to power. In response, IRC and NSC, in collaboration with numerous organizations and individuals directly impacted by retaliation, have launched the #ProtectImmigrantVoices campaign to highlight this widespread pattern of retaliation and demand an end to these practices.

Timed to launch on the eve of the election and coinciding with a feature in The Intercept, the #ProtectImmigrantVoices campaign makes the case for why it is more critical than ever to protect the rights of immigrants to speak freely and organize collectively. By exposing the government’s playbook of threats, retaliation, and intimidation, and highlighting the continued resistance and resilience of those targeted, we send a clear message: immigrant rights activists and immigrant communities will not be silenced.  

Please join our campaign by: 

Sample Tweets 

  1. .@ICEgov and others are engaged in a widespread campaign to silence immigrants. Arrests, deportations, raids, and surveillance—all part of a plan to deny activists their constitutional right to free speech. #ProtectImmigrantVoices immigrantrightsvoices.org 
  1. Over 1K instances of retaliation against immigrant rights activists. @DHSgov @ICEgov @CBP @theJusticeDept and other agencies chilling immigrant speech in our communities. Map at immigrantrightsvoices.org. #ProtectImmigrantVoices
  1. Immigrant rights defenders have exposed an inhumane immigration system. @ICEgov @CBP @the JusticeDept and others have tried to silence them 1000+ times. Their voices have never been more important. immigrantrightsvoices.org #ProtectImmigrantVoices 

Additional sample posts are available via our social media toolkit here. Graphics are available for download here

Contacts:

Chiraayu Gosrani
NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic
Email
P: 919-801-8569

Eleuthera Sa
NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic
Email
P: 646-269-3011

En Español:

NUEVO MAPA EXPONE MÁS DE MIL INCIDENTES DE REPRESALIAS Y VIGILANCIA DEL GOBIERNO CONTRA ACTIVISTAS DE DERECHOS DE INMIGRANTES

En respuesta a los esfuerzos generalizados para silenciar a las comunidades de inmigrantes, la Clínica de Derechos de los Inmigrantes de la NYU y la Coalición Nuevo Santuario lanzan la campaña #ProtectImmigrantVoices

Para publicación inmediata – 

1 de noviembre 2020 — La Clínica de Derechos de los Inmigrantes de la NYU (IRC) y la Coalición Nuevo Santuario (NSC) anuncian el lanzamiento del sitio web Immigrant Rights Voices y la campaña #ProtectImmigrantVoices. El sitio web Immigrant Rights Voices presenta un mapa interactivo que documenta más de mil casos de represalias contra los defensores de los derechos de los inmigrantes por parte de numerosas agencias del gobierno federal y destaca los relatos personales de los líderes de los derechos de los inmigrantes que han sido arrestados, encarcelados, vigilados y deportados por su activismo. Al abusar de su inmenso poder en un intento de silenciar las voces disidentes en las comunidades de inmigrantes, el gobierno está pisoteando flagrantemente nuestro derecho de la Primera Enmienda a decir la verdad al poder. En respuesta, IRC y NSC, en colaboración con numerosas organizaciones e individuos directamente afectados por represalias, lanzaron la campaña #ProtectImmigrantVoices para resaltar este patrón generalizado de represalias y exigir el fin de estas prácticas.

Programada para ser lanzada en vísperas de las elecciones y coincidiendo con un artículo de The Intercept, la campaña #ProtectImmigrantVoices explica por qué es más crítico que nunca proteger los derechos de los inmigrantes a hablar libremente y organizarse colectivamente. Al exponer cómo el gobierno hace amenazas, represalias e intimidación, y al resaltar la resistencia continua y la capacidad de recuperación, enviamos un mensaje claro: los activistas de derechos de los inmigrantes y las comunidades de inmigrantes no serán silenciados.

Por favor únase a nuestra campaña por: 

Hashtag de la campaña: #ProtectImmigrantVoices // #ProtegeVocesInmigrantes 

Tweets de muestra

  1. .@ICEgov y otros están involucrados en una campaña para silenciar a los inmigrantes. Arrestos, deportaciones, redadas y vigilancia: todo es parte de un plan para negar a los activistas sus derechos constitucionales. #ProtectImmigrantVoices immigrantrightsvoices.org
  1. Más de mil casos de represalias contra activistas por los derechos de los inmigrantes. @DHSgov @ICEgov @CBP @theJusticeDept y otras agencias enfrían el discurso de los inmigrantes en nuestras comunidades. Mapa: immigrantrightsvoices.org. #ProtectImmigrantVoices
  1. Los defensores de los derechos de los inmigrantes han expuesto un sistema de inmigración inhumano. @ICEgov @CBP @TheJusticeDept y otros han tratado de silenciarlos más de 1000 veces. Sus voces nunca han sido más importantes. Immigrantrightsvoices.org #ProtectImmigrantVoices

Publicaciones de muestra adicionales están disponibles a través de nuestro kit de herramientas de redes sociales aquí. Los gráficos están disponibles para descargar aquí.

Contactos:

Chiraayu Gosrani
NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic
Email
P: 919-801-8569

Eleuthera Sa
NYU Immigrant Rights Clinic
Email
P: 646-269-3011

###

Ravi’s Case is Back in the Second Circuit, but His First Amendment Retaliation Claim Lives On

Dear friends,

Thank you for your support of Ravi and Amy over the years. We are writing to let you know that we recently received word that the Supreme Court has sent Ravi’s First Amendment case back down to the Second Circuit for a second look. 

Today’s order from the Supreme Court does not call into question the Second Circuit’s ruling that deporting immigrant-rights activists in retaliation for their political speech violates the First Amendment.  Such retaliation remains illegal and wrong.  The only question posed by today’s order is whether federal courts have jurisdiction to hear such First Amendment claims, and for multiple reasons, they clearly do, and Ravi’s legal team welcomes the opportunity to brief the jurisdictional issue further in the Second Circuit.

While today’s order will prolong the case, we remain hopeful that justice will continue to prevail at the Second Circuit and that nothing will change the ultimate outcome: ICE cannot weaponize the immigration laws to silence its critics. And, while this case again proceeds before the Second Circuit, a judicial stay of Ravi’s deportation remains in place.

Please stay in touch as we share further updates. Ravi and Amy are particularly grateful for your support during this time because the ongoing uncertainty and looming threat of deportation has been and continues to be overwhelming. Your support is a source of comfort and inspiration through the worst of times.

Together, back in 2018, we told ICE that they can’t deport a movement. It’s true. The movement is still here, and so is Ravi, and we will keep fighting. Thank you for standing with us.

With love and gratitude,
Ravi’s Defense Committee

Press Release: Supporters of Immigrant Rights Leader Ravi Ragbir Hold Solidarity Rally On Day of His ICE Check In

ASC_9620

Photo by Gili Getz

Ragbir not detained but must check in again July 23

Today at Foley Square in Lower Manhattan, 150-200 community members rallied to support immigrant rights leader Ravi Ragbir for his check in with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Ragbir was accompanied by a delegation of elected officials and faith leaders to his appointment inside 26 Federal Plaza. Although he was not detained, Ragbir must return on July 23.

At the rally, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams told the assembled crowd, “I happen to have the privilege of being a citizen. And everybody who has privilege has to use that to protect those who don’t, those who are being abused and oppressed. That is our duty to stand in the gap. It is our duty to make sure we are lifting up those who have been oppressed by a system…. How do you have a life when you have to check in every six months and you don’t know what’s going to happen?”

Pastor Kaji Dousa, Senior Pastor, Park Avenue Christian Church and co-chair, New Sanctuary Coalition, said at the rally, “Ravi Ragbir is one of the strongest forces in the immigration movement, standing up with and for righteousness, rights, and the soul of our city & nation. For his work, ICE has tried to silence and disappear him. Ravi belongs right here, in his home, New York City, which stands with him every step of the way. When he walks out of ICE today, he will walk right back into his activism. Because the government of this impeached President cannot and will not stop this movement.”

Congressmember Yvette Clarke, who also spoke at the rally and accompanied Ragbir inside the ICE office, said “I was honored to accompany Ravi, a highly revered human rights activist to his check in today, joined by Congressmember Nydia Velasquez. Of course there was a lot of bureaucratic tousling but we ultimately got into his check in. He is stayed again for another six months, but this system needs to be changed. He is no threat to our communities. He has been lawful in his presence and we look forward to his vindication.”

Alina Das, Ragbir’s attorney said, “When ICE detained Ravi two years ago, they said it was because of public safety. But we are the public, and we are safer because Ravi is here. ICE targeted Ravi because he spoke out against a cruel and unjust system. He is still here because the public has spoken out for him. We are grateful that Ravi is still with us, and we will continue to fight to protect the rights of all immigrants.”

Ragbir’s wife, Amy Gottlieb, said “We are so grateful to have the support of our legal team, our families, our friends, our elected officials, our faith leaders, as ICE continues to try to exert power over our lives. But we know that we will walk out each time, and that our power as a united community will overcome injustice and lead us to victory.”

Background: Ragbir received his greencard in 1994, but now faces the double punishment of deportation based on a single fraud conviction he received almost twenty years ago. He was given a final order of deportation in 2007 but was placed on an order of supervision in 2008, allowing him to live and work in the U.S. During that time, he became active in the immigrant rights movement, and paid the price for that activism when ICE detained him on Jan. 11, 2018, and tried to deport him.

A federal appeals court has recognized that the First Amendment protects immigrants from retaliation for their protected political speech and has issued a temporary stay of Mr. Ragbir’s deportation. The government is deciding whether to appeal the decision.

###